Evaluation of Some Sustainability Indices in Khuzestan, Agro-Industries Using Multi-Criteria Decision Making Case Study: Maize, Wheat and Sugarcane

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

Abstract

In assessment of agricultural sustainability, all environmental, economic, social and technical aspects must be taken into account. The purpose of this study is to evaluate and compare the sustainability of wheat, corn and sugarcane production in Khuzestan agro-industries. Data were collected from Shahid Rajaie and Debel khazai agro-industries. Indicators such as energy, the risk of chemical fertilizers and biocide pollution, the risk of soil compaction due to machines, air pollution, and employment were used to compare and evaluate the sustainability of farms. For integrated and comprehensive assessment of indicators and farms ranking, the TOPSIS methods were used. Although these indicators and multi-criteria methods did not show a complete overview of sustainability farms, but they were effective in comparing the sustainability of farms and improving their sustainability. The results showed that employment, the risk of soil compaction and nitrogen fertilizer, air pollution and energy indicators had the most important role in the sustainability of farms, respectively. In the wheat farms, except for employment, other indices were better than other farms. The risk of soil compaction due to agricultural machinery in sugarcane farms had been high and had become one of the main problems of these farms .On the other hand, employment in the sugarcane production per hectare was much higher than the production of wheat and corn. The sensitivity analysis showed that the sustainability of farms was very sensitive to the employment, so with a reduction of 25.39% in weight of employment indicator, sugarcane farms were ranked the last.
 

Keywords

References

Ahrens H and Kantelhardt J. 2009. Accounting for farmers’ production responses to environmental restrictions within landscape planning. Land Use Policy, 26: 925–934.
Almasi M, Kiani S h and Loveimi N. 2008. Principles of agricultural mechanization. Jungle Publications. (In Persian).
Anonymous. 1998. Co-operative Approaches to Sustainable Agriculture. Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, Paris. OECD.
Anonymous. 2005. Islamic Republic of Iran: Cost assessment of environmental degradation. Rural Development, Water and Environment Department Middle East and North Africa Region, World Bank.
Anonymous. 2015. Energy balance-sheet. Iran Ministry of Energy. Power and Energy Planting Department Publication. (In Persian).
Anonymous. 2016. Statistical yearbook of agriculture. Publication of Ministry of Jihad-e Agriculture of Iran. (In Persian).
Asakereh A, Shiekhdavoodi M J and Safaieenejad M. 2010. Energy consumption pattern of organic and conventional lentil in Iran, a case study: Kuhdasht County. Asian Journal of Agricultural Sciences, 2(3): 111-116.
Asgharpoor MJ. 2008. Multi-criteria decision making. Publication of University of Tehran. (In Persian).
Bell M. 2003. The use of multi-criteria decision-making methods in the integrated assessment of climate changes: implications for IA practitioners. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences, 37(4): 289-316.
Bhutto AW and Bazmi AA. 2007. Sustainable agriculture and eradication of poverty in Pakistan. Natural Resources Forum, 31:253–262.
Borch K. 2007. Emerging technologies in favour of sustainable agriculture. Futures, 39:1045–1066.
Chen Y, Cavers C, Tessier S, Monero F and Lobb D. 2005. Short-term tillage effects on soil cone index and plant development in a poorly drained, heavy clay soil. Soil and Tillage Research, 82:161-171.
Cole V, Cerri C, Minami K, Mosier A, Rosenberg N and Sawerbeck D. 1996. Agricultural options for mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions. In: Climate Change, Contribution of Working Group II, (Watson RT; Zinyowera MC; Moss R H, eds), pp 745-771. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
Dahimavy A, Ghanian M, Ghoochani OM and Zareyi H. 2015. Process of application of multi criteriadecision making models in prioritizing of water development projects of rural are as in the Khuzestan province. Journal of Water and Sustainable Development, 1(3): 9-16. (In Persian).
Esengunm K, Gunduz O and Erdal G. 2007. Input-output energy analysis in dry apricot production of Turkey. Energy Conversion and Management, 48:592-598.
Gheysari M M, Houdaji M, Najafi P and Abdelahi A. 2007. Assessment of nitrate pollution of groundwater in south-east of Isfahan region. Journal of Environmental Study, 33(42): 43-50. (In Persian).
Halberg N. 1999. Indicators of resource use and environmental impacts for use in a decision aid for Danish livestock farmers. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 76: 17–30.
Hoghooghi Esfahani M. 2014. Agro-industry and Iranians’ agriculture. Samar Publishing House.
Hooshmandan Moghaddam Fard Z and Shams A. 2017. Factors affecting the greenhouse owners’ attitude toward sustainable agriculture in Zanjan Province. Agricultural Science and Sustainable Production, 27(1):165-177. (In Persian).
Jones RJA and Thomasson AJ. 1990. Mapping potential nitrate leaching losses from agricultural land in the UK In: Nitrates and Irrigation (Hamer P J C; Leeds-Harrison P B, eds), pp 37-45. Proceedings of Conference of United Kingdom Irrigation Association Cran"eld Press, Cran" eld UK.
Kazemnejad M, Giran  A, Plow Ch M,  Kianpour A, Nasr Esfahani A and Amjadi O.  2010. Relative Advantage and Supportive Indices of Sugar Cultivars and Industries in Iran. Institute for Agricultural Research Planning and Economics.Khoshnevisan B, Rafiee S, Omid M, Yousefi M and Movahedi M. 2013. Modeling of energy consumption and GHG (greenhouse gas) emissions in wheat production in Esfahan province of Iran using artificial neural networks. Energy, 52(1): 333-338.
Kitani O. 1999. CIGR Handbook of Agricultural Engineering. Vo l, V, Energy and Biomass Engineering.  ASAE publication, ST Joseph, MI.
Kizilaslan H. 2008. Input- output energy analysis of cherries production in Tokat province of Turkey. Applied Energy, 8: 1354- 1358.
Kok R, Benders RMJ and Moll HC. 2006. Measuring the environmental load of household consumption using some methods based on input–output energy analysis: a comparison of methods and a discussion of results. Energy Policy, 34(17): 2744–2761. 
Lee DR. 2005. Agricultural sustainability and technology adoption: Issues and policies for developing countries. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 87: 1325–1333.
Leiva FR and Morris J. 2001. Mechanization and sustainability in arable farming in England. Journal of Agriculture Engineering Research, 79(1): 81-90.
Meng W, Hao C, Li H and Ju M. 2010. Emergy analysis for sustainability evaluation of the Baiyangdian wetland ecosystem in China, Front. Environmental Science Engineering in China, 4(2): 203–212.
Momeni M. 2014. New topics in operations research, Moalef Publications. (In Persian).
Moumenihelali H, Ahmadpour A and Poursaeed AR. 2015. Identifying the most appropriate cultivar for sustainability of rice production system using analytic hierarchy process (AHP). Journal of Crop Production and Processing. 5 (15): 163-173. (In Persian).
Panthi K and Bhattarai Sh. 2008. A framework to assess sustainability of community-based water projects using multi-criteria analysis, First International Conference on Construction in Developing Countries “Advancing and Integrating Construction Education, Research and practice”, Karachi, Pakistan.464-472.
Perman R, Ma Y, Gilvray JM and Common M. 1999. Natural Resource and Environmental Economics, 2nd Ed. Longman, New York.
Pourtaheri M, Sojasi qidari H and sadeghlu T. 2011. Measurement and priority social sustainability in rural regions with using TOPSIS-fuzzy technique based on order preference by similarity to an fuzzy ideal solution (case study: Khodabandeh country rurals in central part). Journal of Rural Research, 1(1): 1-31. (In Persian).
Safaeenezhad M. 2010. Investigation of energy consumption and determination of economical productivity of corn in Kouhdasht. MSc thesis. University of Tehran. (In Persian).
Sami M. 2011. Sustainability analysis of mechanized agricultural systems using fuzzy logic (a case study for two mechanized systems of maize and wheat production). MSc thesis. Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz. (In Persian).
Sartori L, Basso B, Bertocco M and Oliviero G. 2005. Energy use and economic evaluation of a three year crop rotation for conservation and organic farming in NE Italy. Biosystems Engineering, 9(2): 245-250.
Schroll H. 1994. Energy- flow and ecological sustainability in Danish agriculture. Ecosystems and Environment, 51: 301-310.
Shahin S, Jafari A, Mobli H, Rafiee S and Karimi M. 2008. Energy use and economic analysis of wheat production in Iran. A case study from Ardabil province. Journal of Agricultural Technology, 4(1): 77- 88.
Singh S and Mital JP. 1992. Energy in Production Agriculture. Mittal Publication, New Delhi.
Sulaimani A and Mirakzadeh AA. 2014. Analysis and prioritizing of the influencing the factors on dent corn production by AHP method: with emphasis on environmental sustainability. Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, 15(2): 43-54. (In Persian).
Taghavifar H and Mardani A. 2015. Energy consumption analysis of wheat production in West Azarbayjan utilizing life cycle assessment (LCA). Renewable Energy 74: 208-213
Van Calker K, Berentsen P, Giesen G and Huirne R. 2005. Identifying and ranking attributes that determine sustainability in Dutch dairy farming. Agriculture and Human, 22: 53-63.
Van Cauwenbergh N, Biala K, Bielders C, Brouckaert V, Franchois L, Cidad VG, Hermy M, Mathijs E, Muys B, Reijnders J, Sauvenier X, Valckx J, Vanclooster M, Van der Veken B, Wauters E and Peeters A. 2007. SAFE – a hierarchical framework for assessing the sustainability of agricultural systems. Agricultural, Ecosystem and Environment, 120: 229-242.
Vaz C. 2003. Use of a combined penetrometer-TDR moisture probe for soil compaction studies. Empbra agri instrument. Lecture given at the College on Soil Physics Trieste, 3- 21.
Webster J P G. 1999. The challenge of sustainability at the level of the farm. Journal of Agricultural Economics, 50(3): 371- 387.
Yousefi M, Mahdavi Damghani A and Khoramivafa M. 2014. Energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions and assessment of sustainability index in corn agroecosystems of Iran. Science of the Total Environment, 493: 330-335.
Zamani O, Ghaderzadeh H and Mortazavi SA. 2014. Cropping pattern system respect to sustainable agriculture and optimum use of energy “a case of Saqez county of Kurdistan province”. Agricultural Science And Sustainable Production, 24(1): 31-43. (In Persian).
Ziaei SM, Mazloumzadeh SM and Jabbary M. 2015. A comparison of energy use and productivity of wheat and barley (case study). Journal of the Saudi Society of Agricultural Sciences, 14(1): 19-25
JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL SCIENCE AND SUSTAINABLE PRODUCTION
Volume 28, Issue 3
October 2018
Pages 97-113

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics